I did not like
Harry Potter. I only
read about twenty pages as I did not like that poor Harry had to live under the
staircase. Chris wanted me to try J.K. Rowling’s new adult fiction piece after Jon
Stewart interviewed the acclaimed author and gave the book high praise. Since
one of my colleagues let me borrow it, I was keen on giving it a go.
Rowling
may be a good children’s writer, but fails miserably in creating a compelling
adult read. The book is far too
long. The story, which is pretty dull, could have been wrapped up in under two
hundred pages. There are too many
characters. Instead of exploring sub-stories that may have been more gribbing,
Rowling skims over plot lines. For example, I would have enjoyed learning more
of the mental illness that plagues Cubby. There was a grammatical mistake ten pages into the
book. I found this inexcusable of Rowling and Little, Brown publishing. The
social worker breaks confidentiality and it’s glossed over. My work friend and
colleague did not finish the book. She disliked the language immensely. The
language of the uneducated, poor villagers did not bother me as much as the
lack of story and the hollowness of her characters. I have to ask, if this had been Rowling’s first novel, would
there have been more? I sincerely doubt it.
You have talked me out of wanting to read it.
ReplyDelete